IMPLEMENTATION GUIDE
The activities in this book relate directly to Maine Educational Media Association's (MEMA) Information Skills Guide for Maine Educators, available through the Maine State Library. Following are some ideas from the Guide that have been incorporated. Use them as you develop and adapt assessment tools and as you work with electronic literacy -- the result will be sound and effective information skills programs.

BELIEFS ABOUT INFORMATION LITERACY

+ Learning information literacy must always be intrinsically rewarding.

+ Success at information problem-solving encourages further information problem-solving.

+ Information problem-solving should be student-centered within the context of curricular goals. Learners search best about topics they choose.

+ Resource-based teaching works best when teacher-librarian partnerships flourish.

+ Research must be purposeful: to fulfill a need or to create a product that will be used.

+ Students learn to research by researching many different kinds of questions using a wide variety of strategies from a vast field of sources.

+ Information literacy supports a wide range of problem-solving: it is a powerful tool.

+ Research flourishes in a supportive environment.

+ Students need help to become aware of their own research process: how they develop and use inquiry strategies.

+ Students need opportunities to share this awareness with other learners and to compare, explore, observe, and absorb successful search strategies of their peers.



WARNING: How to ruin assessment design in 17 easy steps....


- Keep assessment tools and explanation a mystery until a project is over. Better than shooting yourself in the foot.

- Treat high quality as an option. The students will too.

- Provide too few guidelines. Students may stray from their task, be counterproductive, and feel apprehensive about unclear expectations.

- Provide too many guidelines. There will be no creativity or higher-level thinking skills or growth to measure.

- Assess everything in sight. This will overburden your time before, during and after a task. Students will be so distracted by assessment that the goals of the task will be eclipsed.

- Assess trivia. Your appraisals wonÍt test what youÍre trying to teach. Never assess an information problem that is significant as well as engaging.

- Try only one format of innovative assessment. You'll never find out how "form follows function." Your student profiles will also be skewed.

- Let students assess their peers without instruction or observation. They'll get out the poison pens or else enjoy gossiping.

- Concentrate on end products. Then students won't have a self-adjustment opportunity and you won't get a picture of their process skills.

- Forget assessing non-routine information problems. Assume students can apply their routinized skills flexibly.

- Accept student choices without justification. Then you won't discover misunderstood concepts or have the opportunity for follow-up probing.

- Use invalid rubrics. Avoid deciding just what is exemplary or sufficient or inclusive for a skill on a specific level.

- Just read and watch. Innovations in assessment isn't like ice skating, which requires putting on the skates and getting onto the ice before you really understand.

- Keep your assessment tool from covering what you wanted to measure. Your students will naturally under-emphasize what is not covered.

- Be negative in describing possible researching difficulties or problems in rubrics. Treat them as mistakes or faults, not as points on a continuum or as opportunities for growth.

- Collect no assessment examples that appeal to you. Follow or adapt no colleague's efforts. Keep no journals - highlight no insights or successes. Recognize no strengths to emphasize.

- Trust assessment as an end in itself. Then its use can't participate in supporting and improving student learning.


August 1997
Maine Educational Media Association


Previous Section . . . . SPRINGBOARD's Table of Contents. . . .Next Section